+1 (403) 862-0449

Choosing Paving Material- Concrete or Asphalt?


When it comes to paving, there is always a debate about which medium to choose from. It can be difficult to discern if you should opt for using asphalt or concrete Contractors in the pavement when conducting repairs. Both materials have their unique properties, and there is nothing making one material superior to the other. Both the materials also have ideal properties for different projects. When selecting between asphalt or concrete driveways for garages , there are some advantages as disadvantages to consider. In this article, we will give you a detailed showdown between the two materials. So let’s get to it! 

Asphalt and Concrete-What’s it all about?

Often, people select their paving material established on the costs. Many prefer an economical or inexpensive solution, which is a smart practice. However, sometimes the perfect pavement selection can also become a bargain; but that is not always kind of case. The expenses of asphalt and concrete keep fluctuating regularly, so you could end up with a short-term remedy and expanded material expenditures if you choose a material that appeases your pocket but not the paving requirements.

Comprehending a few fundamental pavement benefits and drawbacks will assist you when it is time to compute your materials—now and later. We have compiled the pros of both the materials to help you understand better what each of them is good at.

Pros of Concrete Pavements

Concrete can reduce future obstacles and tends to have a longer life. The lifespan of concrete pavement is on average of twenty to forty years. Concrete roads are excellent for recent construction and fresh roads in urban regions. Moreover, it is best for road extensions in metropolitan areas and belowground utility repairs. Opting concrete for areas exposed to biological elements or prone to wear over time is also a good decision.

Furthermore, concrete is one hundred percent recyclable therefore, it is broken down and utilized for different construction programs and in new bridges and roads. While concrete demands very few repairs and maintenance, its fuel expenses are also less for the massive equipment and building machinery needed to conserve it. Low fuel expenses imply low emissions, which help in keeping a clean environment.

Both asphalt and concrete propose the possibility of overlays. Overlays compel little construction and all-around maintenance and can work wonders in having the material last long. They also offer salt, UV rays, chemicals, and additional harmful factors resistance like freezing and vehicle spills. 

The primary kinds of concrete overlays are:

  • White capping
  • Ultra-thin white capping
  • Bound overlay
  • Unbonded overlay

 

Cons of Concrete

Generally, the paving expense for concrete is a tad bigger than the one for asphalt. However, in several scenarios, financing a concrete road undertaking can be hard since concrete is not always deemed a short-term remedy. Fixing up a concrete road frequently leads to replacing a whole slab that can drive repairing costs even higher.

While concrete roads are less liable to formulate potholes than asphalt ones, safety is still a motorist concern. Vehicles can often slide on concrete roads more than asphalt roads, particularly in heavy rain or snowy conditions. When considering concrete as your choice, be mindful of all these facts too.

Pros of Asphalt Pavements

Asphalt is less expensive than concrete, and it also takes less duration to construct an asphalt road. Much like concrete, this material is also recyclable, and it can be melted and utilized again. This makes it a highly beneficial aspect for people with concerns about how much asphalt can cost. It is suitable for constructing roads for rural areas maintenance as certain types of thick asphalt layouts are long-lasting and just compel surface maintenance. Various advances in asphalt overlays rendered these options particularly cost-efficient and fast for country and city roads. 

The choices for asphalt overlays are:

  • Publication
  • Recycling
  • Milling and filling
  • Narrow overlays
  • Modified blends
  • Open-graded friction methods
  • Superpave
  • Stone-matrix
  • Continual pavements

Drawbacks of Asphalt Pavements

Asphalt is extra popular than concrete, however, that does make it ideal for all situations. Naturally, it does come with a few drawbacks. Regions that get constant heavy rains and have longer icy conditions can get deteriorated asphalt roads from severe weather situations and wear and potholes are rather common on asphalt pavement, too.

The maintenance crews have to make frequent visits to the same pothole many times in a season because the asphalt tends to break down as it freezes and thaws. This leads to inefficiencies and increases in expenses over time. So, these are some of the disadvantages you have to be ready for with asphalt.

Conclusion

And that’s all there is to it! While concluding the showdown between asphalt or concrete pavement, there is no straight answer.  The distinct traits in each will ultimately be important in making your final decision. It solely relies on the particular situation and the budget scenario. Therefore, when you have to pick one out of the two, you will need prior detailed planning and experience to decide which material will work best for your situation. We hope this article helps in making things easier for you.

SEO Credit - MRC SEO Consulting